Sex education is de rigueur up here in Canada, thank god. We don’t have to constantly grapple with the “abstinence only” crackpots that are hijacking the American school system, despite overwhelming support for a more comprehensive sex ed. Remember, “abstinence only” is a gateway curriculum to creationism. Nonetheless, the Globe and Mail reported yesterday that some parents are concerned that these programs are too explicit and the pupils too young. What’s more embarrassing than having to buy a condom at the drug store for a school assignment? Having the national media report that you went crying to your mommy over it, that’s what.
The larger question looms: do parents have the right to censor what the schools are teaching? And the answer is no. They can certainly impact the curriculum by voicing their opinions and concerns. In fact, I would encourage parents to actively engage themselves in their children’s school work and to teach their kids about critical thinking on all fronts. But we send our children to public schools and give the nod to the prevailing orthodoxies and most of us expect the teachers and trustees to uphold basic academic principles. (Others, like this guy, would be first in line at the book burning for the sake of our children’s naivety. And others simply opt out and home school their children.)
Even though sex education is as much a health initiative as it is a school subject, parents need to let the schools do what they will. For the most part it will be the kids who need it the most, whose parents are the least likely to broach the topic on their own, who will be the most uncomfortable. And whose parents are most likely to complain. (This teacher makes a good case for a frank approach to human physiology from a young age before shame and embarrassment kick in.
Does it work, though? Last year ABC reported on a study that showed a 50% decline in teenage pregnancies among those who had gone through a comprehensive sex ed program compared to those who had learned only about abstinence. There was a 60% drop when compared to those who had no sex ed at all. It just stands to reason that when condom use is the expected norm, more young adults will conform to that expectation.
I have an infant and a near-three-year-old, so it’s easy for me to be clear headed. I don’t have to worry about my babies growing up and exposing themselves physically and emotionally for a long time. Of course sex is going to be a touchy topic for parents. (All the more reason to leave the nitty-gritty in someone else’s hands.) Beyond all the “risks” associated with unprotected sex, there is a responsibility and an emotional maturity that should accompany sexual activity. All that parents can do is help their children develop that maturity, which includes staying true to their own moral compass.
(Image courtesy of Look PDF.)
9 replies on “Sex in the Schools”
My 5-year-old recently told me that girls don't have bums, they have "gi-ANT-ah's". lol… you're right when you say that we don't really need to think about sex-ed yet.
But as I type this, I start wondering: isn't this actually the beginning of sex ed? Teaching the correct names for parts, teaching comfort about our bodies and what they do (farts included!), respecting other people's bodies no matter how different… Aren't we starting the sex ed now? Especially with children watching their mother's bodies change with pregnancy…
Thoughts, anyone?
I have mixed feelings on this one.
We recently learned our 10 year old got a D in sex ed. Not that she doesn't talk about body parts and functions uncomfortably at home but maybe in a school setting with friends it's more embarassing? I think sex ed really should start maybe a grade or two later than it does for that reason. But that would also mean parents would have to be more open to talking about sex and the body and answering questions their children may have. I agree with Michelle, that sex ed really does start at toddler age when they're discovering their own parts and are learning the correct names and seeing mommy and daddy and how their parts are different or even their parts compared to their parents. But I still think school sex ed is kind of awkward for a 9 or 10 year old to sit through… I don't think they're mature enough to handle it without being incredibly embarassed. I remember trying to get my mom to write me a note so I didn't have to go one year. Lol. Anyways, those are my thoughts!
Having attended a Catholic school and thus receiving zero sex education beyond a mortifying talk in grade nine about our periods, I must say I was somewhat shocked by the frank and open discussions happening in the grade 7 & 8 classes in my school. An amusing side-effect of an "open concept" school such as the one I work in is that periodically on my way to the photocopier I get to hear snippets of conversation around birth control, body parts, STDs…they really get into it. I'm glad that my local-public-school-attending offspring will someday soon get the chance to put all their body part vocabulary to good use.
Hmmm. I got a full disclosure Sex Ed experience at St. Joe's. Replete with a wooden penis for demos. Could have just been the teacher, though.
Oops – accidentally responded to myself instead of you.
Really? Could be things have changed…I imagine now with the new curriculum schools don't have a choice…they can't "opt out" of mandatory expectations as far as I know…
Did you take phys. ed past grade nine? Maybe they saved the chat for kids in the older grades…too bad for those of us who dropped it as soon as we were humanly able.
Nope, it was Grade Nine Gym. And the year was … 1992-1993, I'm pretty sure. It could be things had changed and the Catholic schools had to teach the basics, but I know the teacher seemed very eager, too. I can't imagine they mandated props!
By the way, I think everyone is right and sex ed does start with an unabashed and frank attitude toward body parts from day one.
I do think it all depends on the teacher's own comfort level. My husband teaches grades 7/8/9 and coincidentally while teaching the sex ed component, our 7 year old asked him, "what are boys' balls for?". His answer: ask your mother.
lol